RSCDS Book 2 says "Walsh's Caledonian Country Dances 1748-1760.

The crib diagram says this comes from Walsh, 1760.

Both Walsh and Jackson published collections entitled Caledonian Country Dances around this time, but I can't find anything by either from 1760. The collections I can search do not contain a dance with this name.

Walsh writes:

The 1st Cu. foots it and cast off The 1st Cu. foots it again, 1st Man casts down and the 1st Wo. cast up The 1st Man Heys with the 2d and 3d Wo. 1st Wo. Heys at the same Time with the 2d and 3d Men First Man Heys with the 2d and 3d Men, 1st Wo at the same Time Heys with the 2d and 3d We. The 1st Man foots it with the 3d Wo. and turns her, the 1st Wo. does the same at the same Time with the 2d Man Then the 1st Man foots it with the 2d Wo. and turns her, the 1st Wo. does the same at the same Time with the 3d Man The 1st Cu. leads through the 2d and 3d Men, and turn in the 2d Cu. Place Then the 1st Cu. leads through the 2d and 3d We. and turn in the 2d Cu. Place.

Walsh's music consists of four 4 bar strains, each repeated.

Walsh spells the title "Athol Brays".

RSCDS Book 9 says that Walsh published this in Caledonian Country Dances, ~1748, but the earliest I have been able to find is ~1760.

Walsh writes:

First Cu. hey contrary sides then on your own sides the 1st Cu. foot it to the 2d Wo. and turn her the same to the 2d Man the 1st and 2d Cu. foot it and Right hands across Foot it and Left hands across back again cross over one Cu. and turn Right and Left at top

Walsh spells "Canongate" as "Conongate".

Cannongate is a major street in historic Edinburgh (gate=street), and a "cadger" is a carter who brings produce to market.

RSCDS Book 12 attributes this to Johnson's Caledonian Country Dances of 1748 but it appears earlier.

According to Robert Keller's site this appeared in Walsh's 2nd Edition of Caledonian Country Dances, but I only have access to the 3rd wherein Walsh writes:

The 1st Cu. foots it and casts off then foot it again, and the Man casts off, and the Wo. casts up figure contrary sides figure on your own sides Foot it corners and turn ∴ foot it other corners and turn ∵ Hey contrary sides foot it to your Partner and turn it out.

Johnson published the same figure in about 1742.

The music consists of four 4 bar strains.

There are 8 sub-figures with a mark between them, suggesting that each strain should be repeated. Unfortunately the figures seem take different amounts of time. I'd expect The 1st Cu. foots it and casts off to take 4 bars, but I'd expect figure contrary sides to take 8.

So perhaps Walsh means only half of a figure of eight. That would take 4 bars.

But we still have Hey contrary sides. That takes 8 bars (or maybe 6, but not 4). Could we do half a hey? No, that leaves the corners in the wrong place. Could the 1s do half a hey while everyone else does a full hey? Then we need to make sure the 1s don't bump into the 2s+3s as the 1s set and the corners finish.

This solution does not seem a good one, but I can't think of a better. I doubt it's what Walsh intended.

Could the final strain be played 3 times? Walsh does use a pecular mark at the end of this sub-figure. That just seems worse.

Does Walsh intend the music to be played at four counts per bar rather than two? But most of the sub-figures fit into 4 bars...

The RSCDS attributes this dance to Johnson (who published it in ~1748), but Walsh published it first.

Walsh writes:

Hey on the Men's side Then foot it to Partners then to sides turn single after Each then the 1st Man turn 3d. Cu. half round and cast up into the 2d Place The Wo. do the same back again change sides and foot it cast up change sides and foot it cast off

The music consists of two 4 bar strains.

RSCDS Book 12 attributes this to Johnson's Caledonian Country Dances of 1748 but it appears earlier.

Walsh published Kiss Quick Mother's A'Comeing (sic) in his The Compleat Country Dancing-Master Book 2, 3rd Ed. ~1740 Given that this is the third edition, the dance may well have appeared earlier but I don't have access to the earlier editions.

Johnson republished it a few years later in his Caledonian Country Dances of ~1748.

In 1735 Walsh a different figure named Kiss me fast my Mother's coming. The Merry Medley, 1749 published yet another figure named Kiss me quick my Mother's coming.

Anyway in 1740 Walsh writes:

Each strain twice

First Man kiss quick the 2d Wo. and cast off and go the whole figure round the 3d Cu. and stand in 2d Cu. place And the 1st Wo. do the same 1st man heys with 3d Cu. at the Bottom and the 1st Wo. heys at top with 2d Cu. at the same time Then 1st Cu. cast up to top and go the whole Figure and cast off into the 2d Cu. place

Music consists of two 8 bar strains both repeated.

Note the kiss has been replaced by a bow

RSCDS Book 12 attributes this to Johnson's Caledonian Country Dances of 1748 but it appears earlier.

According to Robert Keller's site in Walsh's Caledonian Country Dances, 2d Edition he published a dance called The Reel of Glames with essentially this figure. Then in his The Second Book of the Compleat Country Dancing-Master, The 3d. Edition, ~1736, he published a dance called The Cleaver Lad, or The Gin I was a Bonny Lad with the same figure.

In Wright's Compleat Collection of Celebrated Country-Dances, Vol. 1 he published a dance called The Reel of Glamis with the same figure. And this one I can find online.

Later Johnson published the same figure and called the dance The Reel of Glamis.

Wright writes:

Each Strain twice

The 1st Man turns the 2^d Wo. and fall back and turn S. the 1st Wo. sett to the 2^d Man, and fall back and turn S. the 1st Man change places with the 2^d Wo. then the 1st Wo. change places with the 2^d Man, then all four meet and turn S. then the 1st Cu. being in the 2^d Cu. place, lead thro' and cast off

The music consists of 2 four bar strains, both repeated. Given that they need to be played at four counts per bar to fill out the figure.

There is one big problem with this description of the figure: both the 1s and the 2s end the corner changes progressed by improper, and there is nothing in the description to get them proper. But the description doesn't quite fill up the music, and there is easily room to throw in hole in the wall cross with partner.

Walsh writes:

The 1st Man Heys with the 3d Cu. his Partner at the same Time heys with the 2d Cu. Then the 1st Man Heys with the 2d Cu. 1st Wo. at the same Time Heys with the 3d Cu. First Cu. leads thro' the 2d and 3d We. and turn in the 2d Cu. Place First Cu. leads through the 2d and 3d Men and turns at Top The 1st Cu. Back to Back and cast off and turn The 2d Cu. does the same First Man leads the 2d Wo. off and turns her First Wo. leads the 2d Man off and turns him, 1st Man cast off at the same Time.

Walsh spells the dance "Soldier Ladie" rather than "Sodger Laddie".

Walsh uses a 32 bar jig tune repeated twice, while the RSCDS has cut the dance length in half.

RSCDS Book 12 attributes this to Johnson's Caledonian Country Dances of 1748 but it appears earlier.

According to Robert Keller's site Walsh published a dance called The Yellow Hair'd Laddie in his Caledonian Country Dances. Book the Second published ~1737.

Some years later Johnson published a dance with the same name and figure in his Caledonian Country Dances...ye 3d. Edition with Additions. A copy of this is online.

Johnson writes:

The 1^st. Cu. lead thro' the 2^d. Cu. & turn in their own Places, then Back to Back and turn The 2^d. Cu. do the same with the 3^d. Cu. Then the 1^st Cu. cast behind the 3^d. Cu. and lead up to the Top and turn then Back to Back and Right Hand & Left to the end of the Tune —

The music consists of 2 eight bar strains, both repeated.

What to make of The 1^st. Cu. lead thro' the 2^d. Cu. & turn in their own Places? What are "their own Places"? Sometimes that means their original places, and sometimes it means their progressed places. The RSCDS thinks it means their progressed places (which means the 2s must move up), but the next instruction The 2^d. Cu. do the same with the 3^d. Cu. suggests that the 2s and 3s are adjacent, which won't happen if the 2s have moved up. RSCDS seems to assume that's a misprint, and that Walsh means "1s" instead of "3s".

But if we assume Walsh meant what he wrote we still get a consistent dance. I think The 1^st. Cu. lead thro' the 2^d. Cu. is probably an abreviation for "1s lead down and cast back to place". We've got 4 bars of music at 3 counts a bar, and even at minuet pacing that's a lot of music just to lead down one couple, but it's about right to lead down and cast up. Then the 1s can do their turns and back-to-back "in their own Places" at the top of the set. And then the 2s can do the same with the 3s.

In the second half of the dance Walsh says Then the 1^st Cu. cast behind the 3^d. Cu. and lead up, but the RSCDS has them casting down 1 couple and leading up, not the 2 couple cast Walsh asks for

Some sources say the turns in the first 32 bars should be right hand, and some say both hand.

The crib diagram shows the "down the middle" to be with near hands joined but the online instructions say "lead".

The RSCDS attributes this dance to Johnson, and he did publish it in at least two books, but Walsh got there first and he published it in at least three books. Both of them spelt the dance Sulters of Selkerke.

According to Robert Keller's site these dances match the figure of the RSCDS interpretation.

In 1717 Kynaston devised a different dance with this name (also published by Walsh).

Walsh writes:

Note: Each Strain is to be play'd twice over.

The 1st Cu. take Hands, go thro' the 2d, and set to the 3d Cu. then turn about to the 2d Cu. and all four take Hands abreast, lead up and the 1st Cu. cast off The 2d Cu. do the same with the 3d and the 1st Cu. The 1st Cu. figure thro' the 2d Cu. all four take Hands and turn quite round The 1st Cu. cross quite round the 2d Cu. clap Hands and cast off into the 2d Cu. Place

The music consists of two 8 bar strains in cut time (not a jig).

I don't have access to the 1710 publication, but the same figure occurs in John Young's Dancing Master and in later publications by Walsh.

In 1729, John Young wrote:

Note: The first Strain twice, and the last but once.

The 1st Cu. Figure thro' the 2d Cu. Sett and cast off, then Figure thro' the 3d Cu. and turn in the 2d Cu Place The 2d Cu. do the same The 1st and 2d Men Sett to their Partners and change Places, the 1st Man turn the 2d Man with left-hand quite round, the 1st and 2d Wo. do the same at the same Time, then Right and Left half round, and the 2d Cu. cast off, then the 1st Cu. Sett and cast off.

The music consists of a 16 bar strain and a 20 bar strain to be played AAB.

Walsh (and Young) spell the title Lord Killmurry's Delight.

First published by Walsh in 1735, later by Johnson, and Wright in 1740, with more publications later.

Walsh writes:

Note: Each Strain twice.

The 1^st. and 2^d. Men lead thro' the two We. the We. lead thro' the Men and all turn S. the 1^st. Cu. whole figure thro' the 2^d. Cu. and sett and cast off cross over round 3^d. Cu. Lead thro' the 3^d. Cu. and thro' the 2^d. Cu. right and left with the 3^d. Cu.

The music is in cut time and consists of an 8 bar strain (repeated) and a 12 bar strain

Walsh writes:

First Man foot it to the 2d Wo. and cast off into the 2d Man's Place, and the 2d Wo. cast up at the same time into the 1st Wo. Place — Then the 2d Man foot it to y^e 1st Wo. (he being at Top) and cast off into his Place, and the 1st Wo. cast up into her Place then the 1st and 2d Man foot it to their Partners, the 1st Cu. cast off one Cu. take Hands with the 2d. Cu. and lead up, foot it and cast off into the 2d Cu: Place.

The music is two eight bar strains, the first repeated, the second not.

Walsh spells "Glasgow" as "Glascow".

Davis also published this dance in 1748, and also spells "Glascow", I have no idea which published first.